Question 1

Is concrete cheaper than pavers for a patio?

Accepted Answer

Plain concrete is cheaper upfront: $4–$10/sqft vs pavers at $8–$25/sqft. However, over 10 years the total cost gap narrows. Pavers have a major advantage in repairs — individual pavers can be replaced without visible patches, while concrete repairs are always visible. For a 20×20 patio, plain concrete costs $1,600–$4,000 installed vs $3,200–$10,000 for brick pavers. Over 10 years including maintenance, concrete is still typically $1,000–$3,000 cheaper.

Question 2

Is concrete or asphalt better for a driveway?

Accepted Answer

For long-term investment, concrete usually wins. Asphalt is cheaper upfront ($3–$7/sqft vs $6–$15/sqft) but has a shorter lifespan (15–25 years vs 30–50 years) and higher annual maintenance costs. Asphalt requires sealing every 3–5 years and resurfacing every 10–15 years. Over a 30-year period, total cost is often comparable. Concrete is better in hot climates; asphalt is more freeze-thaw tolerant and is often the practical choice in harsh northern climates.

Question 3

What is the cheapest driveway surface?

Accepted Answer

Gravel is the cheapest driveway surface at $1–$3/sqft installed, but it isn't a concrete slab — it requires annual regrading, weed control, and replenishment. Among hard surfaces, asphalt is cheapest at $3–$7/sqft. Plain broom-finish concrete is the cheapest permanent hard surface in mild climates. For a 20-year cost perspective on a 600 sq ft driveway: gravel ~$2,500 total, asphalt ~$6,000–$10,000 total (with maintenance), concrete ~$5,000–$8,000 (minimal maintenance).

Question 4

Are pavers better than concrete in freeze-thaw climates?

Accepted Answer

Generally yes. Individual pavers flex slightly with freeze-thaw cycles and can be re-leveled without full replacement. Concrete is a rigid slab — repeated freeze-thaw stress can cause surface spalling (particularly if not sealed) and cracking over time. However, air-entrained concrete sealed regularly performs well even in cold climates. The repair difference is the bigger factor: a heaved paver can be re-set for $10; a heaved concrete slab section costs hundreds to jackhammer and replace.

Question 5

Is decomposed granite a good alternative to concrete for a patio?

Accepted Answer

Decomposed granite (DG) is an appropriate choice for low-traffic patios in dry, mild climates (Southwest US). At $1–$3/sqft, it's dramatically cheaper than concrete. Disadvantages: not suitable for wet or freeze-thaw climates (it turns to mud when wet), requires annual refreshing, and isn't accessible for wheelchairs or furniture with wheels. It's a good budget option for a back-garden seating area in Phoenix or Tucson; not appropriate for most of the US.

Material	Installed Cost/sqft	Lifespan	Maintenance Cost/yr	Repair Difficulty	Freeze-Thaw	Notes
Concrete	$4–$12	30–50 years	$0.10–0.25/sqft/yr	Moderate	Good if sealed	Most durable, low long-term cost
Brick Pavers	$8–$25	25–50 years	$0.25–0.50/sqft/yr	Easy (replace individual pavers)	Excellent	Higher upfront cost, easier repair
Asphalt	$3–$7	15–25 years	$0.30–0.60/sqft/yr	Moderate	Good	Lower upfront, higher long-term maintenance
Gravel	$1–$3	Indefinite (with topping)	$0.10–0.30/sqft/yr	Easy	Excellent	Cheapest option; not a structural slab
Decomposed Granite	$1–$3	3–7 years before refresh	$0.20–0.40/sqft/yr	Easy	Poor	Southwest aesthetic; not suitable for cold climates

Cost Item	Plain Concrete	Stamped Concrete	Brick Pavers
Installation	$1,800	$4,800	$4,800
Sealing (3× over 10 yrs)	$240 DIY	$1,800 prof.	$120 DG sand
Repairs (probability)	$100	$300	$150
Total 10-year cost	$2,140	$6,900	$5,070

Surface	Cost Premium	Drainage Rate	Durability
Permeable concrete	+$2–$4/sqft over standard	High	Good — requires vacuuming every 1–2 years to prevent clogging
Permeable pavers	+$2–$5/sqft over standard	High	Excellent — joint material is the main maintenance item
Gravel / crushed stone	No premium — this IS gravel	Excellent	Indefinite with top-dressing
Grass pavers	$3–$8/sqft total	Very high	Moderate — grass requires water and maintenance

Concrete vs Pavers vs Asphalt: Full Cost Comparison for Patios & Driveways (2026)

All Materials Side-by-Side

For Driveways: Concrete vs Asphalt Deep Dive

Concrete Driveway

Asphalt Driveway

For Patios: Concrete vs Pavers Deep Dive

Concrete Patio

Brick / Concrete Pavers

10-Year Lifecycle Cost: 20×20 Patio (400 sq ft)

Permeable Options

Concrete vs Alternatives FAQ